Easy High-Protein Bagels (Soft, Chewy & Packed with Protein!)

Jump to Recipe

Forget Store-Bought—These Protein Bagels Are a Game-Changer!

I love a good bagel. I mean, who doesn’t? But I also love not feeling like I just ate a brick of bread that’s going to weigh me down for the rest of the day.

That’s where these High-Protein Bagels come in—chewy, golden, and packed with Greek yogurt, almond flour, and whey protein to keep you satisfied without the crash.

The best part? No yeast, no rising time, and no complicated steps. Just mix, shape, and bake. These are the bagels you never knew you needed but won’t be able to live without.

A Quick Story…

One morning, my kids wanted bagels, and of course, I was out. Rather than run to the store, I decided to whip up a batch of homemade bagels. (Honestly, I thought I’d have to convince them that homemade is better—because, you know, kids.)

But to my surprise, they devoured them. Like, not a crumb left.

The best part? They asked for them again the next morning. That’s when I knew I was onto something.

Why You’ll Love This High Protein Bagel Recipe

✔ High Protein & Satisfying – Thanks to Greek yogurt, almond flour, and whey protein, these bagels pack 15-18g of protein per serving to keep you full for hours.

✔ No Yeast, No Waiting – Skip the proofing process and get straight to baking.

✔ Incredibly Versatile – Use them for breakfast sandwiches, post-workout snacks, or a sweet-and-savory treat.

✔ Healthier Than Store-Bought – No preservatives, no weird ingredients—just real, fresh food.

What Makes This Protein Bagel Recipe Better Than the Rest?

Let’s be real—there are a lot of protein bagel recipes out there. But most of them fall into one of two categories: too dry and dense (like eating a hockey puck) or too complicated (who has time for yeast and proofing on a busy morning?).

This Yogurt Bagel Recipe is different because:

1. No Yeast, No Waiting—Just Bake & Enjoy!

Most homemade bagels require yeast, rising time, and a lot of patience. Not these!

Thanks to Greek yogurt and baking powder, these bagels rise beautifully without the extra wait time.

2. Soft & Chewy, Not Dry & Dense

Some protein bagels can be way too dry and tough, but the Greek yogurt and almond flour keep these soft, tender, and chewy, just like a classic New York-style bagel (but healthier).

3. 15-18g of Protein Per Bagel!

Most bagels are carb-heavy with little protein, making you crash before lunch.

These are made with whey protein, almond flour, and Greek yogurt, meaning they’ll keep you full and energized longer.

4. Versatile & Customizable

Whether you’re craving something sweet (think peanut butter and honey) or savory (hello, egg and avocado sandwich), these bagels are the perfect base for any topping.

You can also swap in different protein powders, add seasonings, or mix in seeds to make them your own.

5. So Easy, Even a Beginner Can Make Them

If you can stir and shape dough, you can make these. No fancy equipment, no boiling, no yeast—just mix, knead, and bake.

6. No Artificial Ingredients or Preservatives

Unlike store-bought protein bagels, which are often loaded with additives, these are made with fresh, real ingredients.

You control what goes into them, so you know they’re nutrient-dense and clean.

How to Serve These High-Protein Bagels & The Best Pairings

These High Protein Bagels are super versatile, making them the perfect base for both sweet and savory toppings.

Whether you’re looking for a quick breakfast, a hearty snack, or a post-workout meal, here’s how to make them even more delicious.

🥯 Classic & Savory Ideas

✔ Cream Cheese & Smoked Salmon – The ultimate classic! Add a squeeze of lemon and capers for extra flavor.
✔ Avocado & Egg – Mashed avocado, a sprinkle of sea salt, and a poached or fried egg on top. Perfect for brunch!
✔ Hummus & Veggies – Spread with hummus and top with sliced cucumbers, tomatoes, and sprouts.
✔ Egg, Turkey, & Cheese Bagel Sandwich – A high-protein powerhouse! Add a fried egg, turkey, and melted cheese.
✔ Tuna or Chicken Salad – Use your bagel as a sandwich for protein-packed salads.
✔ Peanut Butter & Sliced Banana – A great balance of protein, carbs, and healthy fats—perfect for an energy boost.

🍯 Sweet & Dessert-Inspired Ideas

✔ Almond Butter & Honey – Drizzle with a little honey or maple syrup for a naturally sweet snack.
✔ Greek Yogurt & Berries – Top with yogurt, fresh strawberries, and a sprinkle of granola.
✔ Cinnamon Sugar Butter – Mix softened butter with cinnamon and a touch of coconut sugar for a warm, spiced flavor.
✔ Nutella & Crushed Nuts – A little indulgence never hurt! Pair with crushed hazelnuts or almonds.
✔ Cottage Cheese & Peaches – High in protein and deliciously creamy.

🍽️ What to Serve These Bagels With

If you’re making these as part of a meal, pair them with:

✔ Eggs & Breakfast Meats – Scrambled eggs, turkey bacon, or smoked salmon for a filling breakfast.
✔ Smoothies or Protein Shakes – A great post-workout meal combo!
✔ Soup & Salad – Use a sliced bagel instead of croutons for a crunch in soups like tomato or chicken noodle.
✔ Coffee or Tea – Because what’s a bagel without a warm drink?

Equipment & Tools

• Mixing bowl – For combining the dough
• Spatula or wooden spoon – To mix ingredients
• Clean surface – For kneading the dough
• Baking sheet – Lined with parchment paper
• Pastry brush – For applying the egg wash
• Measuring cups & spoons – For accuracy
• Oven – Preheated to 375°F (190°C)

The Recipe: The Best Ever High-Protein Bagels

Forget store-bought bagels—these homemade high-protein bagels are about to change your breakfast game!

They’re soft, chewy, packed with Greek yogurt, almond flour, and whey protein, and they come together without yeast or long rise times.

Whether you’re craving a savory sandwich or a sweet, toasted treat, these bagels deliver big flavor, amazing texture, and a serious protein boost.

Plus, they’re so easy to make—you’ll wonder why you haven’t been baking them all along!

What Can Be Substituted in This Protein Bagel Recipe?

One of the best things about these High Protein Bagels is how flexible they are!

Whether you have dietary restrictions, ingredient preferences, or just need to use what’s in your pantry, here are some easy swaps that still deliver amazing results.

Flour Substitutes:

✔ Almond Flour → Oat Flour or Coconut Flour

• If you’re allergic to nuts, replace almond flour with oat flour (for a heartier texture) or coconut flour (but use 1/3 less, as it absorbs more liquid).

✔ Whole Wheat Flour → All-Purpose Flour or Gluten-Free Blend

• Want a lighter texture? All-purpose flour works perfectly.
• Need gluten-free? Use a 1:1 gluten-free flour blend.

Protein Powder Substitutes:

✔ Whey Protein → Plant-Based Protein Powder

• If you’re dairy-free or vegan, swap whey protein for a plant-based protein powder like pea or rice protein. Just note that some plant-based powders absorb more liquid, so you may need a little extra yogurt.

✔ No Protein Powder? Use More Flour!

• If you’d rather skip the protein powder, replace it with an extra ½ cup of almond flour or whole wheat flour.

Greek Yogurt Substitutes:

✔ Dairy-Free? Use Coconut Yogurt or Cashew Yogurt

• Keep it thick! Avoid runny yogurts, as they can make the dough too sticky.

✔ No Yogurt? Try Cottage Cheese or Buttermilk

• Blend cottage cheese for a smooth texture or use buttermilk for a softer, slightly tangy flavor.

Egg Wash Substitutes:

✔ Egg-Free? Use Milk or Olive Oil

• Brushing the bagels with a little almond milk, coconut milk, or olive oil before baking will still give them a golden crust.

Sweetener Substitutes:

✔ Honey → Maple Syrup, Agave, or Monk Fruit

• If you want a lower-carb option, skip the honey altogether or replace it with monk fruit sweetener.

---

Bonus: Fun Add-Ins & Toppings!

Want to mix things up? Here are some delicious add-ins:
✔ Savory: Add garlic powder, onion flakes, or shredded cheese to the dough.
✔ Sweet: Mix in cinnamon, vanilla extract, or mini chocolate chips.
✔ Toppings: Try everything bagel seasoning, sesame seeds, poppy seeds, or sunflower seeds for extra crunch.

Final Thoughts: Your New Favorite High-Protein Bagels!

If you’ve made it this far, congratulations—you’re officially a bagel-making pro (or at least well on your way).

And let’s be honest, once you realize how easy, delicious, and protein-packed these are, you’ll never look at store-bought bagels the same way again.

Think about it—why settle for overpriced, nutrient-lacking bagels when you can make chewy, golden perfection right in your own kitchen?

Plus, these aren’t just any bagels; they’re high-protein, no-yeast, no-nonsense bagels that keep you full, energized, and feeling like a breakfast champion.

And the best part? They’re totally customizable. Feeling fancy? Go full smoked salmon and capers. Need a post-workout boost? Slather on some almond butter and banana.

Want to feel like a New Yorker? Grab a cup of coffee, eat one standing up, and pretend you’re late for a meeting.

Honestly, these bagels are so good, you might find yourself making double batches just to keep up with demand.

Trust me, once your family, roommates, or even your dog (who will beg for a bite) get a taste, they’ll be requesting these on repeat.

So, whether you’re here for the protein, the convenience, or just because you love a dang good bagel, this recipe is for you.

Give it a try, experiment with toppings, and most importantly—enjoy every bite.

Now, go forth and bake! And if you make these, tag me on Instagram @Dealiciousness so I can see your creations (and maybe steal your topping ideas). Happy baking! 🥯

FAQs: Everything You Need to Know About Protein Bagels

1. Can I make these bagels without protein powder?

Yes! If you’d rather skip the protein powder, you can replace it with extra almond flour or whole wheat flour. Just note that skipping protein powder will slightly lower the overall protein content, but they’ll still be delicious and nutrient-dense!

2. How do I store these high-protein bagels?

Once cooled, store your bagels in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3 days. For longer storage, freeze them in a sealed bag for up to 2 months—just pop one in the toaster when you’re ready to eat!

3. Can I make gluten-free protein bagels?

Absolutely! Swap the whole wheat flour for a gluten-free 1:1 flour blend and use a plant-based protein powder instead of whey. Just be mindful that different flours absorb moisture differently, so you may need to adjust the yogurt slightly to get the right dough texture.

Have more questions? Drop them in the comments—I’m always happy to help!