Best Mustard Subscription Box

The Condiment Sidekick You Need in Stock: Mustard Subscription Boxes of 2024

Get ready… This is the ultimate flavor journey with 2024’s Top Mustard Subscription Boxes. Each box in this lineup celebrates taste, bringing a unique twist to your meals with every jar. Immerse yourself in my handpicked selection and discover the golden, earthy, and piquant world of mustards that will add an unforgettable zing to your kitchen creations. The Best Mustard Subscription Box is a Few Clicks Away!

Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission if you purchase through the links on this page. The product recommendations are solely based on our genuine opinions and experiences.

various shaped and sized jars of mustard

In my kitchen, mustard stands shoulder to shoulder with essentials like olive oil and sea salt.

Whether it’s whisking together a salad dressing that becomes legendary in family lore, elevating my tuna salad to absurdly delicious heights, or being the pièce de résistance on my beloved charcuterie boards – Mustard perfectly pairs with cured meats and cheeses, and a touch of honey – oh, the magic it creates as well as health benefits like helping to relieve heartburn!

Are you Running out of mustard regularly? UNTHINKABLE.
You need a Mustard Subscription box to take all of your cares away.

With new exciting mustards to try or even just customize your own monthly subscription order, I’m sure we will find the right Best Mustard Subscription Box For you.

a kitchen fully stocked of many different kinds of mustard

It’s the hidden gem that consistently delivers that “Wow, that’s good! reaction. From the tangy zest of a Dijon to the subtle sweetness of honey-infused varieties, the taste of mustard in each jar opens a door to endless culinary adventures.

As I spread, marinate, and experiment with this golden delight, join me in exploring the best mustard subscription boxes of 2024. Let’s discover the endless possibilities that this vibrant condiment brings to our tables.

Ready for a taste trip that promises to dazzle your palate? Let’s get into it.

My Top 3 Picks

My Top Pick (Best Overall): Avoy Mustard

several jars of artisanal mustard with mortar and pestle in the foreground

Best Mustard Essentials: Sun Valley

jar of mustard surrounded by soft pretzels and a ramekin with dipping mustard

Best Artisanal: The Curvy Spoon

What To Look For In Mustard Subscriptions?

When choosing a mustard subscription box, there are several key factors to consider:

  1. Variety and Flavor Profiles: Look for subscriptions offering many different flavors, from classic to exotic, ensuring a diverse culinary experience.
  2. Quality of Ingredients: Preference goes to boxes that use natural, high-quality ingredients, avoiding artificial preservatives and flavors.
  3. Subscription Flexibility: Consider options that allow customization in terms of duration and frequency, as well as the number of jars per delivery.
  4. Price Point and Value: Evaluate the cost per jar and any additional savings for longer subscriptions to ensure good value for money.
  5. Shipping and Accessibility: Check if the subscription offers free shipping and if they deliver to your location.
  6. Customer Experience: Consider the brand’s reputation for customer service and satisfaction.

    two men testing the texture of a big batch of mustard
    Image Credit: Sun Valley Mustard

What Are The Best Mustard Subscriptions?

With these key factors in mind, let’s dive into the individual mustard subscription boxes. Each has unique offerings that cater to varying tastes and preferences, ensuring there’s a perfect match for every mustard enthusiast.

My Top Pick (Best Overall): Avoy Mustard

several jars of artisanal mustard with mortar and pestle in the foreground

Key Benefits:

  • Handmade and artisan quality
  • Variety of unique flavors like Beer, Thyme, Cranberry Spice, and Gourmet Sun Dried Tomato
  • Flexible subscription options: 3, 6, or 12 months

Avoy Mustard’s subscription box invites you into a world of homemade mustards, each bursting with unique stories and flavors. Crafted from scratch with brown and yellow mustard seeds, their commitment to natural, chemical-free practices is a testament to mindful cooking. If you cherish making wholesome choices in the kitchen, from opting for non-toxic cookware to handpicking the purest ingredients, you’ll find that Avoy’s Mustards are a perfect match for your culinary ethos.


  • The first order ships immediately, so you don’t have to wait for the next month
  • Shipping is free
  • Eco-friendly and non-toxic approach to mustard making


  • The artisanal course ground texture might not suit all preferences

Bottom Line: Perfect for culinary enthusiasts who value artisanal, eco-friendly products that align with their commitment to making mindful choices. Ideal for those who enjoy exploring new flavors in their cooking.

Best Mustard Essentials: Sun Valley

jar of mustard surrounded by soft pretzels and a ramekin with dipping mustard

Key Benefits:

  • Four classic flavors that effortlessly satisfy basic mustard needs
  • Committed to 100% fresh, all-natural ingredients without artificial additives
  • Gourmet quality products coupled with exceptional customer service

Sun Valley Mustard’s subscription brings a sense of authenticity and care to your table. Each jar, crafted with a less smooth, more artisanal texture, reflects their dedication to quality and natural ingredients. The option to choose your flavors adds a personal touch, making each delivery eagerly anticipated.


  • Enjoy 20% savings with a subscription
  • Shipments typically arrive a few days after ordering
  • Most flavors come in convenient squeeze bottles for easy use


  • Limited to only four flavors, which might not cater to those seeking extensive variety

Bottom Line: Ideal for anyone looking for high-quality, simple, and trustworthy mustard options with the added benefit of supporting a local business.

Best Artisanal: The Curvy Spoon

Key Benefits:

  • Hand-crafted, small-batch production ensures high quality
  • Artisanal flavors inspired by global cuisines
  • Affordably priced at approximately $7 per jar

The Curvy Spoon’s “Mustard of the Month” subscription stands out for its artisanal approach. Each flavor, inspired by cuisines from around the world, is a testament to their craftsmanship and culinary creativity. With a limited selection of 16 flavors, each gift pack promises a unique, gourmet experience.


  • Diverse and globally inspired flavor profiles
  • The brand also offers various spice blends, adding to its culinary appeal
  • Great value for artisanal quality


  • Limited to 16 flavors, offering a more exclusive but less diverse range.

Bottom Line: A great choice if you’re seeking affordable, artisanal, and delicious mustard with a global twist. Perfect for culinary explorers looking for unique flavors.

Best From Around the World: Month Club Store

jar of international mustard

Key Benefits:

  • Diverse international selection, perfect for global flavor enthusiasts
  • Flexible subscription: choose jar quantity, frequency, and duration
  • 4.9/5 Gold Star customer satisfaction

Month Club Mustard of the Month Club features interesting, globally sourced mustards. Their subscription box is highly customizable, catering to both casual tasters and serious connoisseurs. The Month Club commitment to customer satisfaction is reflected in their stellar online ratings.


  • Free shipping on all orders from Mustard Month Club
  • Selection includes many award-winning mustards from international competitions like the Napa Valley Mustard Festival
  • Subscribers to Month Club can explore mustards not commonly found at your local grocery store


  • Limited shipping options, currently not available for Canada or International delivery

Bottom Line: The Month Club mustard subscription box is zan excellent choice for those who enjoy discovering new and unique flavors from around the globe, especially with the convenience of customizable subscription options.

Best Variety: National Mustard Museum

several jars of a variety of mustards

Key Benefits:

  • Over 6,000 different mustards for unparalleled variety
  • Authentic expertise as hosts of the World Mustard Competition at the actual Mustard Museum
  • Each shipment includes 3 diverse mustard jars

Delve into the extensive world of mustards with the Mustard Museum subscription. Each gift pack from this renowned national mustard museum offers three unique mustards, providing a glimpse into their expansive collection. It’s a journey rich in history and flavor, ideal for enthusiasts and curious tasters alike.


  • Great value with jars priced between $10-$13, with more savings in annual subscriptions
  • Flexible subscription options
  • Free shipping


  • May not regularly include the latest artisanal brands

Bottom Line: An excellent choice for those who appreciate the history and diversity of mustards, offering a comprehensive and educational mustard experience.

What Are The Reasons To Get a Mustard Subscription

Perhaps the better question would be, “Why wouldn’t you get a mustard subscription?!”

stone ground mustard being spooned out of a jar
Photo by Elevate on Unsplash

Here are the best reasons why you should:

  1. Exploration of Unique Flavors: Mustard subscriptions offer a range of flavors from classic to unique, enabling you to explore different culinary traditions and tastes.
  2. Convenience and Variety: Regular deliveries mean you always have a variety of mustards at hand, perfect for cooking, dressings, marinades and so much more.
  3. Quality Ingredients: These subscriptions often focus on high-quality, natural ingredients, offering a healthier, more flavorful option compared to mustards at your local grocery store.
  4. Culinary Inspiration: Each jar can inspire new recipes and add an unexpected twist to familiar dishes.
  5. Gifting Potential: They make the perfect gift pack for the foodies in your life or anyone looking to expand their culinary horizons.
  6. Supporting Artisans: Many subscriptions come from small, artisan producers, supporting small businesses and traditional mustard-making methods.
  7. Mastery of a Versatile Ingredient: A mustard subscription is a fantastic way to learn about and master this versatile condiment. It enables you to discover the various ways mustard can improve and elevate a meal.

Mustard: A Culinary Chameleon

It’s time to rethink what you know about mustard. Far from just a topping for hot dogs, mustard’s versatility in the kitchen is almost infinite.

hot dog with mustard, ketchup and relish
Photo by David Thielen on Unsplash

Here are some creative and unexpected ways to incorporate it into your dishes:

  • Elevate salad dressings and vinaigrettes
  • Create savory roast rubs for grilling
  • Add zest to deviled eggs and tuna salad
  • Whip up unique dips
  • Enhance soups with a flavor boost
  • Spread on sandwiches for extra depth
  • Use in marinades to infuse meats with rich flavors
  • Prepare glazes for baked goods, meats, or vegetables
  • Mix into barbecue sauces for a tangy kick
  • Stir into meatloaf, burger patties, or scrambled eggs
  • Blend into mashed potatoes or macaroni and cheese
  • Enhance coleslaw or potato salad dressings
plated salmon being finished with a gourmet mustard sauce
Photo by Edward Howell on Unsplash

The possibilities with mustard are only limited by your imagination. Move beyond traditional uses and discover its potential to transform your culinary creations.

Health Benefits of Mustard

Mustard isn’t just a delightful addition to your meals; it’s a powerhouse of nutrition. Packed with essential nutrients like zinc, omega-3 fatty acids, magnesium, and selenium, mustard offers more than just flavor.

Its seeds are known for their antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects, contributing positively to your health. Plus, it’s low in calories, making it a smart choice for adding zest without the extra calories.

woman with hands over her stomach in the shape of a heart
Image by Alicia Harper from Pixabay

Mustard also aids in digestion and metabolism, making it a beneficial ingredient in any health-conscious diet.


Mustard subscription boxes offer an exciting way to explore diverse flavors, from classic to exotic. These subscriptions are ideal for enhancing your skills in the kitchen, providing a range of options that are both suited to novice cooks and seasoned chefs. Quality ingredients, variety, and the joy of discovering new tastes make these boxes a delightful addition to any kitchen. 

As you consider enhancing your meals and expanding your flavor palette, ask yourself: which mustard subscription will take your cooking to the next level?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the top-rated mustard?

The top-rated mustard varies based on individual preferences and criteria like flavor, ingredients, and texture. Consumer reviews and culinary awards can be good indicators of quality.

What mustard is the healthiest?

The healthiest mustards are typically those made with natural ingredients and without additives or preservatives. Look for mustards with minimal sugar and salt for healthier options.

Which country makes the best mustard?

This is subjective and depends on personal taste, however, countries like France, Germany, and England are renowned for their mustard varieties, each offering unique flavors and styles.

Similar Posts


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *